Outsourcing trends and project management

The internet is changing the trade-off between outsourcing and doing work in-house. It is important for project managers to be aware of this trend. Previously, there were many reasons to do work in-house and only outsource in a very limited set of situations, but now a number of the problems of outsourcing have been either reduced or eliminated by the internet. Project managers should reevaluate when they want to outsource, as there are now many more opportunities than even 5 years ago, primarily driven by technological changes.

The Nature of the Firm

In 1937, Ronald Course, first published his seminal article on the Nature of the Firm and the debate has being ongoing within the field of economics ever since. Basically, there is debate over why firms exist and what efficiencies (if any) they provide over having everyone just work individually on a freelance basis. Some of the reasons for firms to exist include:

  • Reputation – firms have brands and reputation that would be costly for individuals to create and maintain.
  • Search costs – its pretty expensive to launch a Request For Proposal process every time you need make a legal decision, and having an in-house legal team might be more efficient.
  • Friction causes by external contracting – every time you contract with someone outside the firm there are legal costs and a risk that the contract may not be executed as expected. Whereas, within the firm the process is likely to be much smoother.

The impact of technology on outsourcing

The internet is changing this. All of the problems above that justify the existence of firms are starting to be solved by the internet. Reputation used to be relatively hard and costly to measure, but now sites like Amazon can provide informative product reviews, whilst sites like Yelp  in the US, do the same for businesses. Search costs are reducing as sites like Google and Bing make it much easier to find anything. Friction costs haven’t gone away, contracts still exist, but intermediaries now offer services that make this process easier – Mechanical Turk, Elance and Seed are all example of this. Mechanical Turk is Amazon’s tool for having individuals do low level work, such as checking if a photo is correctly titled and getting paid $0.02 per photo. Elance offers outsourcing of larger tasks like preparing a PowerPoint presentation. Seed is AOL’s effort to outsource content creation, Seed submits the description of what sort of news article or photograph is required, for example an article on ‘When Following Warren Buffett is a Mistake’ and anyone can then submit that article and receive a share of the advertising revenue it generates. In all of these cases, the technology is prompting greater outsourcing:

Solution Benefit Previous Solution
Mechanical Turk Outsource low-level analytics Hire the capability in-house
Elance Outsource discrete pieces of work Hire the capability in-house
Seed Outsource writing of online articles Hire the capability in-house

There are still barriers to outsourcing, notably that the quality of what is delivered remains hard to measure objectively in many cases, but there are significantly less blockers than previously and project managers should (re)consider the new opportunities in this area. 

One response to “Outsourcing trends and project management

  1. Great article about outsourcing and definitely on point. I have used Elance providers in the past for both small and large projects and have had great results. What I’ve found is that the more interaction a buyer has with the provider (before selecting them) and the clearer they are with their expectations, the more successful the experienced will be for both parties.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s